• Journal
  • Events
  • IMR
  • More
    Film Mosaic 2023PressAbout CAFxFilm submissions
    Jobs
    Research
    Summer Schools
    Events archive
  • members
  • Become a memberBecome a member
  • Login
  • Social
  • Facebook
  • Vimeo
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
Cancel
Article
·
part of
Corona Essays
·
29.11.21

In Defence of Messiness

If we give up the right to have a say in the mess of our environments, that’s when they become clinical

Written by
Lotte Kofod Møller, Anthropologist and MSc in Social Science and Spatial Design
reading time
00
Health

Imagine the most sterile place you can think of.

Chances are you are thinking of a hospital or maybe a laboratory. White coats, squeaky clean surfaces. A vague smell of cleaning chemicals. That clinical feeling.

These are usually places we might describe as impersonal and a bit cold. Everything is highly controlled. As they should be—in a hospital or a lab. But these places stand in contrast to many of our everyday environments because they have no messiness. There’s nothing random, rather everything has a specific reason, a specific rationale. There’s nothing superfluous.

A certain level of messiness is usually a part of all places and environments. And we have always sought to control that messiness or at least convince each other and ourselves that we could. Think of neatly kept gardens as a display of humans’ control over nature. Neatly designed cities illustrating how life can be orchestrated and organised. With design and planning comes a reduction of messiness or so it used to. With today’s design ideals, we like to incorporate designed mess. Think for instance of the ‘Vild med Vilje’ initiatives, or ‘Wild on purpose’, a movement to encourage more wild nature in Denmark by way of design and planning.

While we prefer to keep the illusion that we can control the mess, we nonetheless thrive with at least a little of it. It’s the thing that gives a place identity because it has elements for us to reflect on. To feel connected to. Attach memories to. We can recognise our personal spaces—say our homes—by the fact that we get to choose the mess. We decide the amount and the location and the shape of the mess. This makes a place personal.

The lack of control is the real source of the sterility of the place, not the amount of disinfectant used.

In responding to the corona outbreak and as an important part of avoiding a spread of the virus, we have a task of designing places that are easy to clean. But at the same time the task is to avoid designing overly controlled environments. For us to thrive in an environment it shouldn’t be clinical or sterile—it should be clean yes, but offer us at least a small degree of mess.

If a place is overly controlled—by someone else—it rarely feels personal. Imagine your living room controlled according to certain standards that are already given. For instance a maximum number of seats with a minimum distance between them. You have nothing to say in the matter, no influence. The lack of control is the real source of the sterility of the place, not the amount of disinfectant used.

If we give up the right to have an influence and have a say in the mess of our environments, that’s when they become clinical and can’t provide anything for us to grab a hold of or to reflect on or relate to. Then they become reduced to a representation of moral—that is sanitary—prescriptions.

So in responding to the corona virus, how many benches to remove from the park? How many toys to remove from the kindergarten? Obviously there is no magic answer. But it’s worth keeping in mind that attachment to places comes from messiness and that to lose these attachments would affect our wellbeing in our environments. Especially with prospects of living with restrictions for a long time, the challenge for designers and others is to ensure that we still feel welcome in all of our everyday environments and that they remain interesting to us.

‍

Sign up to our Newsletter

Hej! If you want to know what CAFx is up to, you can use the form below to sign up to our newsletter, sent every other Friday, and receive updates on our latest projects, events and Journal content directly to your inbox.

Success

Thank you! You have successfully been subscribed to our newsletter.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
  • Corona Essays
    Collection
  • in collaboration with
  • Denne artikel er tilgængelig som PDF.
    Download
  • Tidligere festival år
    The Three Winners of the Film Mosaic Have Been Found
    Inclusivity and the Character of a City
    "We are, in short, reuniting Copenhagen with its displaced landscape, its forgotten foundation"
    LINA Open Call 2023
    Keeping the Relay Alive
    The Manifesto as a Dream Machine
    The Refuge as a Queer Space
    The Party as a Queer Space
    The Clinic as a Queer Space
    Crafting an Intersectional Gaze on Cities, and Three Other Reasons Why Urban Planning Needs Data Feminism
    CAFx' contribution for the new SPACE10 Library
    "Can I Get A Roof Over My Head, Please?" 
    A Room of One’s Own Rooted in an All-Connected World
    Where Does Inclusive Design Meet Film?
    Film and Architecture Workshop Tirana: Leave No One Behind
    Tre begivenheder at se frem til i 2023
    New Platform LINA - OPEN CALL for sustainable architecture
    Den sultne by: Interview med Carolyn Steel
    CAFx' direktør Josephine Michau er valgt som kurator  for Den Danske Pavillon på  Arkitekturbiennalen i Venedig 2023
    Infrastructures of Longevity Takeaways
    Kysterne, tiden og alt, hvad der lever, gror og er i bevægelse
    Two Practical Experiences in Atacama Desert
    Caring Techniques: Making Design Documents Work for Democratic Futures
    In Defence of Messiness
    In the Midst of Concrete Monsters
    Carrying Things Together
    The Fragility of Becoming an Ecosystem of Practicess
    Landscape of Terms: Expanding a Lexicon
    Methodologies of Softness
    An Interview with Soft Agency
    Publikation: Pandemic Resilient Cities
    Den humane by
    Firmitas, utilitas, venustas
    Arkitekturen må fortsat være nysgerrig på sin fremtid, men også på sin fortid
    Politikerne har kun købt den populistiske vinkel på arkitekturens virke
    NO / YES
    Eksperimentalismen leve!
    En by, der fungerer og føles som en skov
    Fremtidens arkitektur handler om relationer
    Tema: Sundhed og arkitektur
    Architecture is Political
    Den kritiske arkitekt
    ”Hvad mener arkitekten?”
    Et involverende narrativ: Skitse til en klimaetisk arkitekturpraksis
    Byen er vores chance for at leve bæredygtigt
    Det er vores pligt som arkitekter at bygge bro mellem kunsten og videnskaben
    Do politicians, administrators and managers still read in these days?
    Klimatilpasning af vores byer er ikke en sag alene for arkitekter, ingeniører eller planlæggere
    Arkitekturen forfladiges, når den reduceres til, hvilken farve teglsten der vælges til at forskønne de bagvedliggende betonelementer
    A call to architects in every part of the profession to take action in their own architectural practice
    Fremtidens arkitektur skal være arkitektur med krop og evigt liv
    De fleste nybyggede boliger er bygget til den samme målgruppe: den velstillede kernefamilie
    Særliggørelsen af det almindelige - en ode til bæredygtigheden
    Det 21. århundredes arkitektur må gøre plads til de små aktører
    Planetære programmører
    Vi står over for et klimaspøgelse, der kræver en total transformation af individet og samfundet
    Arkitektur er samfundskunst
    Kun én kvinde har modtaget Pritzker-prisen som selvstændig arkitekt
    Bydemåde – Arkitekturens manifester mellem krise og kald
    A Conch Manifesto
    Det, som var rigtigt i går, er ikke nødvendigvis det, som er rigtigt i morgen
    Arkitektur er ideologi i fast form
    International Manifest Stafet 2023
    Bogudgivelse: The Welfare City in Transition – A Compilation of Texts and Images 1923 – 2020
    Natalie Mossin og Marianne Kofoed: Kære overborgmester,
    Johan Hage: Kære overborgmester,
    Dan Stubbergaard: Kære overborgmester,
    Arkitektfællesskabet: Kære overborgmester,
    Kenneth Balfelt Team: Kære overborgmester,
    Nils Holscher: Kære overborgmester,
    Jonas Sangberg: Kære overborgmester,
    Thing Brandt Landskab: Kære overborgmester,
    Martin og Rosa, STED: Kære overborgmester,
    Jan Koed: Kære overborgmester,
    Jesper Kusk Arkitekter: Kære overborgmester,
    Ed Durie: Kære overborgmester,
    Einer Seerup: Kære overborgmester,
    Juul Frost Arkitekter: Kære overborgmester,
    Anna Esbjørn: Kære overborgmester,
    Hanne Schmidt: Kære overborgmester,
    Adept: Kære overborgmester,
    Future Architecture Rooms
    The World’s Recovery
    Curated Apertures
    Potential of Borders and Shared Cultural Infrastructure
    Nye sammenhænge
    Covid-19 and Cities
    Re:habilitation
    The Corona Curtains
    A Naked City and a Creative Lockdown
    Spring Doesn’t Pause
    Tanker i en forandret by
    The Corona Crisis and the Built Environment
    Byen blev pludselig meningsløs
    The Very Nature of the Pandemic is about Human-Environment Relations
    Pandemics & Architecture
    Pandemien vil sætte sig dybe spor
    We Need to Reorganize the City
    Morten Birk Jørgensen: Kære overborgmester,
    Christian Pagh: Kære overborgmester,
Corona Essays
Show all
Articles
-
24.11.21
The World’s Recovery
We who live in industrialized society have almost completely lost the ability to see the world in its otherness: an-human, unfathomable, existing, shifting, fecund, myriad.
Articles
-
24.11.21
We who live in industrialized society have almost completely lost the ability to see the world in its otherness: an-human, unfathomable, existing, shifting, fecund, myriad.
Articles
-
9.11.21
Covid-19 and Cities
The impacts of COVID-19 have only been felt for less than two months in North America yet the number of articles already declaring the end of the city as we know it is staggering
Articles
-
9.11.21
The impacts of COVID-19 have only been felt for less than two months in North America yet the number of articles already declaring the end of the city as we know it is staggering
Articles
-
23.11.21
Potential of Borders and Shared Cultural Infrastructure
We set the borders out as the first thing but no longer think about their lifecycle or how we treat them
Articles
-
23.11.21
We set the borders out as the first thing but no longer think about their lifecycle or how we treat them
Articles
-
23.11.21
A Naked City and a Creative Lockdown
For the first time in 30 years, I was able to feel the energy of a city I thought I knew. A naked city perceived for the first time completely different.
Articles
-
23.11.21
For the first time in 30 years, I was able to feel the energy of a city I thought I knew. A naked city perceived for the first time completely different.
Related
Articles
-
9.11.22
Publikation: Pandemic Resilient Cities
Det tværfaglige samarbejde mellem CAFx, EAHR og Think-Fast udkommer med en online publikation om byens post-pandemiske udfordringer.
Articles
-
9.11.22
Det tværfaglige samarbejde mellem CAFx, EAHR og Think-Fast udkommer med en online publikation om byens post-pandemiske udfordringer.
News
-
23.1.23
Film Submission x 2023
We are now open for submissions for our 10th edition of Copenhagen Architecture Festival taking place in June 2023.
News
-
23.1.23
We are now open for submissions for our 10th edition of Copenhagen Architecture Festival taking place in June 2023.
Podcasts
-
9.11.21
Epidemihistorie
Tre podcasts der kortlægger, hvordan sygdomme og dens behandlinger har formet samfundet og arkitekturen
Podcasts
-
9.11.21
Tre podcasts der kortlægger, hvordan sygdomme og dens behandlinger har formet samfundet og arkitekturen
  • Journal
  • All posts
  • Podcast
  • Articles
  • Film
  • Collections
  • Events
  • Upcoming
  • Livsform
  • Archive
  • Film mosaic
  • About Film Mosaic
  • Watch
  • Guidelines
  • Education material
  • Mere
  • About CAFx
  • Press
  • Jobs
    Research
    Summer Schools
  • Social
  • Facebook
  • Vimeo
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
Listen on
Apple Podcast
Listen on
Google Podcast
  • Contact
  • Copenhagen Architecture Festival
    Halmtorvet 27
    1700 København V

    E. info@cafx.dk
    CVR: 43054066
  • 2022 © Copyright Copenhagen Architecture Festival — CAFx · Privacy policy · Terms & Conditions
Cookies
We use cookies and trackers (including from third parties) to understand and optimize your browsing experience
DatapolitikAccepter